When You Know What to Do But Can’t Do It

A client came to our coaching session fresh off her most successful business year. The numbers were good. The clients were happy. By all external measures, she was thriving.

She had clarity too - a roadmap in her head for transitioning to a different business model, one that felt more aligned with where she wanted to go. She knew exactly what she needed to do. The steps were clear.

And yet, she couldn’t make it happen.

“I know what I need to do,” she told me, a note of sadness creeping into her voice. “I just can’t seem to move forward. I have no energy left to get this going.”

As she walked me through her situation, one word kept surfacing: depletion. She’d mention the transition, then circle back to feeling depleted. She’d describe her vision, then return to that same word. Her own language was telling us something.

The Gap Between Who We Say We Are and Who We Actually Are

There’s a concept from organizational theorists Chris Argyris and Donald Schön that I find myself returning to again and again in coaching and organization work: the difference between espoused theory and theory-in-action.

Espoused theory is what we say we believe, what we say we value, what we say we’re going to do. It’s the version of ourselves we present to the world—and often, the version we genuinely believe is true.

Theory-in-action is what our actual behavior reveals about what we believe and value. It’s who we are in our daily choices, in how we spend our time and energy, in what we’re actually capable of doing right now.

For my client:

Espoused theory: “I want to transition to this new business model”

Theory-in-action: “I can’t seem to move forward. I have no energy left to get this going.”

The gap between these two isn’t a character flaw. It’s not a lack of discipline or commitment. It’s information.

When someone is capable and clear but still can’t execute, we typically reach for productivity solutions: better time management, clearer goals, more accountability. We assume the problem is in the doing.

But what if the gap is telling us something else entirely? What if it’s showing us that restoration needs to come before execution?

When Safety Is Missing, Creativity Goes Offline

This isn’t metaphorical. Polyvagal theory helps us understand what’s happening physiologically. Our nervous system is constantly scanning our environment for cues of safety or threat—a process called neuroception. When our system detects enough signals of safety, our ventral vagal pathway is activated. This is the state where we have access to our full range of capacities: creativity, connection, complex thinking, and the ability to take purposeful action aligned with our values.

But when safety cues are missing or threat cues are dominant, our nervous system shifts into sympathetic (fight/flight) or dorsal vagal (shutdown) states. In these survival states, the creative, connective, values-aligned part of us literally goes offline. We’re left operating from a different part of our brain entirely—one focused on survival, not growth. We do what’s familiar, what’s proven, what keeps the wheels turning.

I asked my client a different question: “What makes you feel safe and calm in your life right now? What relationship, environment or moment gives you that sense of safety?”

She paused. Thought about it. And couldn’t name one.

Without cultivated safety—without that foundation of felt security—we simply cannot access our most creative and authentic selves. No amount of clarity can bridge that gap. No amount of capability either.

My client’s depletion wasn’t an obstacle to overcome on her way to the transition. It was her nervous system telling her it didn’t have the safety foundation needed to take creative risks. Her theory-in-action—”I have no energy left”—was speaking truth her espoused theory couldn’t yet acknowledge.

She didn’t need a better roadmap. She needed restoration.

What the Gap Is Telling You

If you find yourself in this place—knowing what you want to do but unable to do it, saying you value one thing but living another—I invite you to get curious about the gap rather than ashamed of it.

The gap isn’t failure. It’s your system giving you information about what needs to happen first.

Perhaps, like my client, you need to cultivate more safety in your life before you can take the creative risks you’re calling yourself toward. Perhaps you need restoration before you need strategy. Perhaps the most important work isn’t accomplishing what you say you’re going to do—it’s paying attention to why you can’t, and what that’s telling you about what you actually need.

This is where real transformation begins: not in pushing harder, but in listening deeper.

A Question for You

As you read this, what moments of inaction came to mind?

When have you known what you wanted to do but couldn’t move forward?

And if you pause right now and recall that moment—what signs did you notice in your body or life that were calling you to pause?

I’d love to hear what this brings up for you. Leave a comment and share what you’re noticing.

References:

Argyris, C., & Schön, D. A. (1974). Theory in Practice: Increasing Professional Effectiveness. Jossey-Bass.

Dana, D. (2023). Attuned: Practices for Relating Through the Polyvagal Lens. W. W. Norton & Company.

Stay in the conversation

New reflections on restorative leadership, straight to your inbox. No noise.